((Time zones, Y U prevent dead people from having a faster conversation D': ))
Aaah, finally some interesting stuff happening on the thread of the living in an epic duel of lovely pink ladies. Allow me to put on my thinking cap *grabs a brain that was lying around, refrains from eating it and places it on her head* and throw some random thoughts around.
I assume every post could be a lie so I'm very fuzzy-brained about everything.
Already 8 votes for Cassie despite her defence. From what I've seen so far, people were reluctant to vote without a good reason, so I assume those votes have some thought behind them.
Still 4 votes for Ginz, which could be (could be) Cassie + the mafia. They know that the voters' identities will be shown in the morning, though.
(Draco and Jay have one vote each. Wouldn't it be funny if they had just voted for each other?)
If Ginz is the Spy, she would have been really lucky to see the Arsonist visiting Christos just before being doused herself. That would not be the most incredible coincidence we've had in a game, though.
(I won't exclude the possibility that Christos is the Arsonist and lied about being doused after the first night just to get off the suspect list.) (What is this "far fetched" you speak of?)
(Cassie mentioning that she got sorcerer'd right after Christos' post seemed strangely like an apology by the Arsonist. xD But Cassie wouldn't let it seem that way, would she? Unless it's a double bluff.)
What makes Cassie seem suspicious to me is that she accused Pixie and THEN accused Ginz right back, which is a bit much.
Ginz had a more innocent sounding defence.
Random thought: do doused people stop showering?
Torkie seems to be playing a Detective or Warden type. Can't tell if that's playing straight or bluff or double bluff or triple bluff or @___@
All the people who make rather short one-liner posts, or who haven't posted much yet, or not at all... I do wish the living could grab them and start talking to them and get more reactions out of them. They're either suspicious and avoiding attention, innocent and watching cautiously from the sidelines, or too busy to post and unfortunately going to seem suspicious later.
Coaster seems to have claimed neutral alignment. *takes note*
Celes pretty much claimed the Vigilante role. If even I caught it, it was obvious. *mentally adding five layers of bluff to that claim*
She also mentioned getting to eat ice cream.
Alyssa, did you send her some, or was it just a story? (That could be helpful for interpreting her posts.)
And apparently Christos' neighbor "Totoro" was acquainted with you?
THAT MUST MEAN CHRISTOS IS THE WARDEN AND SPOKE WITH NEIGHBOR PINEAPPLE BECAUSE SHE'S ALSO A NEIGHBOR and so that means she's innocent because she has the same alignment as you What is this "over interpretation" you speak of?
I keep getting the impression that I'm missing hints while reading Jay's posts. xD His character would make a good Amnesiac, at least. And those colourful words, now that we're used to seeing them in his posts, would be an excellent way to give more subtle hints to the town. (Well that's how I would use them >_>; )
(On another note, man, if I'd been a living Magician later in the game, I would have loved to try grabbing a potentially wicked or night immune person and swapping them with the person who seems like the next murder target.) (And magnificently failed if I'd accidentally got a good person killed instead < 3 Oopsiiiie!)
That's all I've got so far, I still need to go over more posts and maybe contradict myself later. Now watch me slowly get proven wrong by the next revelations! \o/
*Edit instead of new post because I'm just talking to myself for the moment:*
The posts of the Living Thread are interesting again. I thought I had noticed some inconsistencies. Special thanks to Sporty's and Coaster's and Jay's brains for working so clearly.
Mmm delicious brainsCassie... still sounds suspicious and cornered to me. Either it's a good bluff, or she just sounded unfortunately ambiguous in her earlier posts.
Daring important town roles to reveal themselves so early in the game to counter-claim her... that doesn't sound like an innocent's defence either.
To me, "I fear nothing" is exactly what someone says when they do have something to fear. ^^;
And immediately accusing other people seems exactly like what someone does when they are feeling guilty! Gah, Cassie, Y U do that T_T
The first accusation against Pixie was on the base that Pixie had posted and then fallen silent. There are SO many other people who have been silent, though. I posted and fell silent earlier, because I was sick. And it's easy to challenge someone to counter-claim when they're not around.
If Cassie really is the detective, she might just have been reluctant to reveal her role too directly in that first accusation, though.
The detective is the most obvious role to claim when you don't want to be executed. It would be quite a coincidence for the first big accusation to land on the detective; however, judging from past games, weird coincidences are totally possible.
Ooh, threatening Jay that the town would find him suspicious after her death. That threat was a good move. x3 (I don't find Jay suspicious yet. Well, not more than anyone else, anyway. Because /someone/ in town needed to step in and do some brain work.)
I do hope that the town isn't accidentally killing the detective...
But there's still the problem of who started the vote against Ginz in the first place.
And if Ginz was an evil role trying to get Cassie executed, the town would know she was lying as soon as Cassie's role was revealed post-mortem, so Ginz would get executed or Warden'd immediately after. I wouldn't have taken that risk.
There's still a good possibility that Ginz is the evil role in this, in which case she played the part of a victim quite convincingly.
Well at this point I'm just waiting for the death. :'D In any case, if an innocent is executed, the town will probably catch the other suspect somehow. I hope the Warden can start interrogating people.
It shall be our duty to avenge innocents from beyond the grave through our MIGHTY WEAPON the Clairvoyant. (Are you feeling mighty? Hope you're feeling mighty!)
